Sell Graded Pokémon Cards
the Smarter Way

List your PSA, CGC, or BGS graded slab as a CatchaBreaks break. Five collectors each pay a spot fee. When all 5 fill, the draw runs automatically and you receive payment via PayPal — no auction waiting, no lowball DMs, no fee stacking.

List a Break Today →
Only 10% fee — vs 13.25% on eBay PSA · CGC · BGS · ACE · AGS Admin verified PayPal payout

Why CatchaBreaks Beats eBay for Graded Slabs

Factor CatchaBreaks eBay Facebook Groups
Seller fee 10% 13.25% + PayPal 0% (but risky)
Payment security Collected before draw Chargeback risk F&F = no protection
Time to sell Hours to days 7–10 day auction Days to weeks
Lowball offers None — you set the price Constant Constant
Listing fee Free Varies Free
Verification Admin-reviewed Self-listed No oversight
Buyer dispute risk Low — draw is final High — eBay sides with buyers No recourse

How to Sell Your Graded Card in 5 Steps

1

Create your CatchaBreaks account

Sign up with your email. Takes 30 seconds. No credit card required.

2

Submit your listing

Click "List a Break" in the nav. Enter the card name, grading company (PSA, CGC, BGS, etc.), cert number, description, and price per spot (minimum $20). Upload a clear photo of the actual slab — not a stock photo.

3

Admin approves your listing

Our team verifies the cert number and reviews the photo before your break goes live. This usually takes a few hours. Fakes and misrepresented cards are rejected — this protects you as a legitimate seller too.

4

Five collectors fill your break

Once live, collectors browse and claim spots. When all 5 spots are claimed, the draw runs automatically. You're notified immediately who the winner is.

5

Get paid, then ship

Payment arrives via PayPal (minus the 10% service fee). You then ship the card directly to the winner using the address the platform provides. Use a tracked, insured service appropriate for the card's value.

Grading Companies We Accept

🏆

PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator)

The most widely recognized grading company. PSA-graded cards typically command the highest market values. All PSA grades (1–10) are accepted.

🟢

CGC (Certified Guaranty Company)

Known for detailed sub-grades and half-point grades. CGC Pristine 10 and Gem Mint 10 slabs are highly sought after by collectors.

🔵

BGS / Beckett

Beckett Grading Services offers both numeric grades and distinctive black labels for pristine cards. BGS 10 and 9.5 grades are very popular with buyers.

📋

Other Companies

We also accept ACE, AGS (Arena Grade Sports), and ICG graded slabs. All listings require a valid cert number that can be verified on the grading company's website.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it better to sell graded Pokémon cards on eBay or CatchaBreaks?
For most graded slabs, CatchaBreaks offers faster sales and lower effective fees. eBay charges 13.25% final value fee, while CatchaBreaks charges 10%. There are no listing fees, no auction sniping, and no waiting 10 days for an auction to end. Breaks often fill within hours or days.
How quickly will my graded Pokémon card sell?
Breaks featuring popular cards or competitive pricing often fill within hours. Less common cards may take a few days. Unlike eBay's fixed auction window, your break stays live until it fills or you close it — no pressure to relist.
What if the break doesn't fill?
If a break expires without filling, all participants are automatically refunded. You simply relist your break or close the listing. There is no listing fee and no penalty — you keep your card.
Can I list a low-grade slab (PSA 5, PSA 6)?
Yes — all grades are accepted. Lower-grade cards should be priced accordingly. The minimum spot price is $20 ($100 total listing price), so lower-grade cards with values under $100 may not be suitable for the platform.
What happens after the draw — do I need to ship immediately?
After the draw, you'll receive the winner's shipping address via the platform. We recommend shipping within 3 business days using a tracked and insured service. Always get a receipt/proof of postage.

Ready to Sell Your Graded Card?

Create a free account and list your first break in under 5 minutes.

List a Break →

Full seller guide →